Beyond WPATH: anti-trans declaration
Beyond WPATH was a 2023 petition created by anti-trans activist Joseph Burgo to attack the World Professional Association for Transgender Health (WPATH). It was signed by many key leaders in anti-trans extremism.
Background
In 2018, several groups began incubating organizations to create an alternate to the Standards of Care, published since 1979 by WPATH. In 2023, WPATH released Version 8 of their Standards of Care, which prompted the declaration.
Complaints
The declaration stated:
“We hold that the authoritative status of WPATH’s Standards of Care is fatally undermined by the following errors and ethical failures:
- The Standards specifically promote the affirmative care model, continuing to endorse widespread medical treatments (drugs and surgery) for trans-identified youth despite rising scientific skepticism that has led Sweden, Finland, France, and the United Kingdom to retreat from that approach.
- WPATH endorses early medicalization as fundamental while these other countries now promote psychosocial support as the first line of treatment, delaying drugs and surgery until the age of majority is reached in all but the most exceptional cases.
- In a correction issued soon after its release, nearly all lower age limits for suggested medical and surgical interventions were removed – an abdication of responsibility for basic child-safeguarding norms.
- A chapter on ethics that had appeared in earlier drafts was eliminated in the final release – a further abdication of ethical responsibility.
- ‘Eunuch’ was included as a new gender identity (not necessarily a physical condition) without convincing evidence for its existence; a hyperlink within the Standards links to an external site that incorporates graphic and sexual fantasy stories portraying the castration of adolescent males.
- A definition of “detransition” fundamentally mischaracterizes it, invalidates the traumatic experience of many who feel harmed by gender-related medical interventions and subsequently revert to living as their biological sex, and offers no guidance for supporting individuals who are coping with the grief and pain of detransition.
- While presented as evidence-based, the Standards of Care fail to acknowledge that independent systematic reviews have deemed the evidence for gender-affirming treatments in youth to be of very low quality and subject to confounding and bias, rendering any conclusions uncertain.”
Signatories
The declaration received over 2,000 signatories.
note: Names are presented as shown on the list, including any affiliations listed. Signatories are not independently confirmed and may not be authentic. The list below and the longer list may contain errors or omissions.
Notable anti-trans activists listed as signatories include:
- Soren Aldaco: Detransitioner
- Cath Allen: Chair, OBJECT
- “Michelle Alleva”: Detrans Advocate
- Laura Becker: Artist and Teacher; Detransitioner
- David Bell: Psychoanalyst and Retired Consultant Psychiat; British Psychoanalytic Society/Royal College
- Keira Bell: Medically transitioned as a minor
- Dr Michael Biggs: Associate Professor of Sociology; University of Oxford
- Heather Brunskell-Evans: Dr Heather Brunskell-Evans; Sociologist of medicine
- Petra Bueskens: Psychotherapist | Academic; PPMD Therapy
- Joseph Burgo: Clinical Psychologist
- Richard Byng: General practitioner and academic
- Elizabeth Chesak: Sovereign Women Speak
- Donovan Cleckley: Concerned parent & educator
- Belissa Cohen: Journalist
- Corinna Cohn: Gender Care Activist; GCCAN
- “Chloe Cole”: Children’s Safety Advocate
- “Toni Cornford”: Founding Member; Canadian Women’s Sex-Based Rights
- Timothy J Courtois: Licensed Professional Counselor (Michigan)
- Michelle Cretella, MD: Pediatrician; American College of Pediatricians
- Stephanie Davies-Arai: Director; Transgender Trend
- Sophie Dechêne: Child psychiatrist; Observatoire La Petite Sirène
- Kathleen Dooley: Attorney at law
- Christina Edge: Detransitioner
- James Esses: Co-Founder Thoughtful Therapists
- Ash Fearnley: Detransitioner, Psychology Undergraduate stud
- Heather Finlay: Womens Rights Network
- Joy Flores: Mrs; Genspect
- Stassja Frei: Founder; Coalition for Biological Reality
- Erin Friday: Attorney – Co-Lead Our Duty; Our Duty
- Sophie Frost: Psychotherapist
- Pamela Garfield-Jaeger: licensed clinical social worker; The Truthful Therapist
- Ghislaine Gendron: Coordinatrice; Women’s Declaration International
- GIGI LARUE: Our Duty USA– West Coast
- Tonje Benedikte Marion Roth Gjevjon: Leader of lesbian performance group Hungry He
- Kathleen A Goonan: MD; Internal Medicine
- Dr. Shlomit Gorin: Clinical Psychologist
- J Gourley: Our Duty
- Miriam Grossman MD: Child, Adolescent and Adult Psychiatrist
- Alasdair Gunn: Massage therapist and scientist; Concerned parent
- Az Hakeem: Consultant Psychiatrist
- Holly Harrington: Concerned Swiss Parents Association
- Linda Hart: Doctor in Social Sciences; Researcher
- Øyvind Hasting: psychiatrist; Vestre Viken HF (Norway)
- Elise Hayes: Concerned parent of trans identified youth; Member of Genspect
- Laura Wiley Haynes: Court Appointed Special Advocate
- Ritchie Herron: Detrans Advocate
- Andrea Heyting: Construction Manager; Trans Woman
- John Higgon: Clinical Neuropsychologist
- Sherri Ingrey: lawyer (retired); Cwsbar
- Marsha Inman: Friends and Family Director; Living Hope Ministries
- Marie Louise Irvine: Dr; General Practitioner
- Peter Jenkins: Co-Founder Thoughtful Therapists
- Jet: Detransitioner
- Andrea Jones: concerned parent; Our Duty Group
- Keith Jordan: Director, Our Duty
- Sarah Jorgensen: Pharmacist
- Kamilla Demeterne Juhasz: concerned parent; Our Duty Group
- Tiffany Justice: Director, Moms for Liberty; Moms for Liberty
- Anne Kalvig: Professor
- Dianna Theadora Kenny PhD: Professor; Consulting psychologist/psychotherapist
- Anna Kerr: Principal Solicitor, Feminist Legal Clinic In
- Susan King: Detransitioner, Psychology Undergraduate stud
- Ann Leduc: Member of The Feminist Legal Clinic and signa
- Martin Levi: Director; Radfems of Canada
- Grace Lidinsky-Smith: Gender Care Activist; GCCAN
- Terri Lipanovic: LGB Alliance Aotearoa New Zealand
- January Littlejohn: Licensed mental health counselor
- Suzanne S Lockyer: Parent; Moms for Liberty
- Michelle Mackness: Clinical Counsellor
- Pip Malone: Detransitioner
- Courtney Maloney: Concerned parent of trans identified youth; Member of Genspect
- Jessie Mannisto: Writer & Editor; Third Factor Magazine
- Maud Maron: MD, CCFP(AM), MScCH, FCFP, FRACGP
- Tania Marshall: Clinical Psychotherapist
- Julia Mason MS MD FAAP: Pediatrician; SEGM
- Celine Masson: Professeur des universites
- Julie Maxwell: Paediatrician
- Kathleen McGill: Environmental Management; Coalition for Biological Reality / Concerned
- Hamish McGregor: LGB Alliance Aotearoa New Zealand, Gay Men Ad
- Carrie D. Mendoza, MD: Director, FAIR in Medicine
- Quentin L Van Meter: M.D., F.C.P.; President, American College of Pediatricians
- Martine Michaud: Photographe; Pour les droits des femmes du Qubec
- Christopher Robert Miller: Detransitioner
- Caelan Monaghan: Guernsey Women’s Rights Network
- Michele Moore: Professor
- Stella O’Malley: Psychotherapist; Genspect
- “Keene Prodan”: Ph.D.; “Affirmation Generation” Original Documentary
- Lori Regenstreif: MD, CCFP(AM), MScCH, FCFP, FRACGP
- Jay W Richards: Director and Senior Fellow; The Heritage Foundation
- Avi Ring: Retired Chief Scientist, Mol. Neurosc.
- Jan Rivers: former public servant / independent researche; Fully Informed NZ
- Lynne Robertson: Environmental Management; Coalition for Biological Reality / Concerned
- Jane Roper: Guernsey Women’s Rights Network
- Lisa Salamone: Certified Life Coach for Moms of ROGD Teens/Y
- A. Luis Sanchez: LGB Alliance USA
- Lauren H. Schwartz: MD, FAPA; Integrative Psychiatrist, Psychotherapist
- Martha J. Shoultz: Attorney; Partners for Ethical Care
- Nancy K Stade: Psychotherapist | Academic; PPMD Therapy
- Sara Stockton: LMFT; Aisling Marriage & Family Therapy , PLLC
- Aaron Terrell: Gender Dysphoria Alliance
- Leonore Tiefer: PhD (Psychology); Former co-director, Montefiore Sex and Gender
- Carrie Turner: Ms; Womens Rights Network Scotland
- Micheline VanDenburgh: Environmental Management; Coalition for Biological Reality / Concerned
- Liza Vespi: Founding Member; Canadian Women’s Sex-Based Rights
- Michael Wheat: LGB Alliance Aotearoa New Zealand, Gay Men Ad
- Melanie Whyte: Parents of Adolescents with Gender Distress
- Bronwyn Williams: Solicitor; Feminist Legal Clinic
- Janice Williams: Chair, OBJECT; www.objectnow.org
- Stephanie Winn: Licensed Marriage and Family Therapist, write
- Robert Withers: Jungian analyst; BPC And UKCP
- Lauren Wohl-Sanchez: Public health communications consultant
- Jean L Wyldbore: Community Health Worker (retired); Coalition for Biological Reality, Australia
- Kyla Zalapski: Parent; Parents of ROGD Kids
- Kim Zander: Chairwoman; Womens Space Vancouver
- Dawn Zook: Director; Transgender Trend
The following signatories have similar names as noted anti-trans activists but may be different people:
- Ben Appel: Licensed Psychologist [not author Ben Appel]
- Jennifer Block: Concerned Parent [possibly Jennifer Block]
- J. Cohn: MD; Internal Medicine [possibly “J. Cohn”]
- Torren Danowski: Concerned parent and grandparent
- Graham Linehan: Manager of Elder Programs, Feminist, Mother [possibly Graham Linehan or an impostor]
Resources
Beyond WPATH (beyondwpath.org) [archive]
Was this helpful?
Support my work!