Skip to content

media

Matt Christiansen is an American media personality and anti-transgender activist. Christiansen is associated with the intellectual dark web, described as a gateway to the far right.

Background

Matthew “Matt” Christiansen was born on October 18, 1987 and resides in Bozeman, Montana.

Christiansen frequently discusses political issues on YouTube.

References

Olson, Warren (June 18, 2021). The Orwellian Function of Transgender Ideology. Matt Christiansen Media https://www.mattchristiansenmedia.com/outback-observer/2021/6/17/the-orwellian-function-of-transgender-ideology

Media

Matt Christiansen (December 10, 2015). Transgender, Transage, and Transreason | Meet Me on Mars. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uBGZq7XCBOE

Ribeiro MH, Ottoni R, West R, Almeida VAF, Meira W (2019). Auditing Radicalization Pathways on YouTube. arXiv.org (PDF) https://arxiv.org/abs/1908.08313

Resources

Matt Christiansen (mattchristiansenmedia.com)

Twitter (twitter.com)

Twitch (twitch.tv)

YouTube (youtube.com)

(minds.com/mlchristiansen)

Sam Harris is an American writer, podcaster, and anti-transgender activist. Harris is a key figure in the intellectual dark web (IDW), described as a gateway to the far right. In 2020, Harris disavowed the IDW, and in 2021 Harris symbolically returned the “imaginary membership card to this imaginary organization.”

Background

Samuel Benjamin Harris was born on April 9, 1967 in Los Angeles, California to parents who were both in entertainment. Harris left Stanford after an experience with MDMA and spent about a decade learning spiritual practices in India and Nepal. Harris returned and completed a bachelor’s degree in 2000. Harris earned a doctorate from UCLA in 2009.

Harris published the book The End of Faith in 2004. harris has gone on to be a critic of religion, especially Islam. Harris has debated many people on religion, including Rick Warren, Deepak Chopra, Jean Houston, William Lane Craig, and Reza Aslan. Harris has also appeared in debated on religion with anti-trans extremists Andrew Sullivan, Jordan Peterson, and Michael Shermer.

Harris and spouse Annaka Gorton have two children.

Podcast

Harris began the podcast Waking Up in 2013, later renamed Making Sense.

References

Young, Sam (Oct 26, 2022). Sam Harris, J.K. Rowling, and the Cesspool of Anti-Trans Activism. An Injustice! https://aninjusticemag.com/sam-harris-j-k-rowling-and-the-cesspool-of-anti-trans-activism-3e2753e5b6da

Peter Clarke is an American writer and anti-transgender activist.

Clarke has shown support for several anti-trans extremists, including Michael Shellenberger, Amy Hamm and Jesse Singal.

Background

Peter M. Clarke was born in August 1985 in Port Angeles, Washington. Clarke earned a bachelor’s degree from Western Washington University in 2007 and a law degree from University of the Pacific in 2010.

Clarke wrote for Reputation.com, LegalMatch, FindLaw, Indiegogo, and Judicial Council of California. Clarke wrote the books Politicians Are Superheroes and The Singularity Survival Guide. Clarke has also written for Areo MagazineThe HumanistThe American Spectator, Quillette, and Free Inquiry Magazine. Clarke founded Jokes Literary Review.

Clarke is based in Sacramento, California.

Anti-trans activism

Clarke wrote a sympathetic profile of anti-trans extremist Michael Shellenberger, part of a sustained effort by a faction of anti-trans activists critical of progressivism.

Clarke wrote a sympathetic profile of anti-trans extremist Jesse Singal after a panel featuring Destiny, Vaush, and Emma Vigeland discussed Singal’s extensive anti-transgender activism:

To be clear, if Singal did have horribly offensive views about trans people or gender dysphoria, then, of course, the Seder-Vigeland position would be correct—or, at least, defensible. Some people are, unfortunately, transphobic in the genuine sense of the term. But Singal is not. It is certainly possible to disagree with Singal’s position. But it is not possible to find an ounce of bigotry in his writing. He is, in this respect, a “good liberal.”

Clarke (2023)

Clarke’s view on gender:

  1. Gender is cultural and is great to play with if you want
  2. Technology is going to radically change our biology but can’t do much yet
  3. People should hold their identities lightly rather than pretending like they’re sacred

Clarke’s view on sex:

If someone is biologically male, they can’t change to biologically female. The medical interventions are crude, often harmful, and not incredibly successful right now. The culture war on this topic, in my view, would be more civil if identity was less important to people.

References

Clarke, Peter (October 17, 2023). How Jesse Singal Became the Symbol of Polarization on the Left. Merion West https://merionwest.com/2023/10/17/how-jesse-singal-became-the-symbol-of-polarization-on-the-left/

Clarke, Peter (May 13, 2022). Can California Change?—An Interview with Michael Shellenberger. Quillette https://quillette.com/2022/05/13/can-california-change/

Resources

Peter M. Clarke (petermclarke.com)

Twitter (twitter.com)

LinkedIn (linkedin.com)

Substack (substack.com)

Wrongspeak was a podcast produced by Quillette and hosted by anti-trans activists Debra Soh and Jonathan Kay.

The show featured a number of other anti-transgender activists and people associated with the so-called intellectual dark web, a loose alliance described as a “gateway to the far right.”

Episode

  • #17 – The Family Business with Barbara Kay
  • #16 – Our Lines are Open: Confessions of a Talk Radio Host with Matt Gurney
  • #15 – Khalistan in Canada with Balraj Deol and Niru Kumar
  • #14 – Such a Shanda with Naftuli Moster
  • #13 – Comedy Without Hashtags with Craig Lauzon
  • #12 – Transparency Evangelism with Minds CEO Bill Ottman
  • #11 – 35 Years of Wasted Time with Edward Hertrich
  • #10 – That’s Not Funny with Mike Ward and Jamie Kilstein
  • #9 – TERF v. Trans with Meghan Murphy and Julie Rei Goldstein
  • #8 – Gender Dysphoria 101 with Dr. Susan Bradley
  • #7 – Short Cut: Assaulting pro-lifers with Marie-Claire Bissonnette
  • #6 – Academic Mobbing with Jonathan HaidtBret Weinstein & Rebecca Tuvel
  • #5 – David Frum on Discourse in Trump’s America
  • #4 – Wrongspeak Review Vol. 1 with Ed the Sock and Adrienne Batra
  • #3 – Too Young to Transition? (featuring Susan Bradley)
  • #2 – The Shepherd Effect with Lindsay Shepherd
  • #1 – James Damore’s Inconvenient Brain

Uncomfortable Truths: The Reality of Gender Identity Ideology is an anti-transgender propaganda series by Travis D. Brown.

Announced participants from 2023 include conservative and anti-trans extremists:

The series includes anti-trans extremists sharing their views on specific trans issues, as well as Peter Boghossian asking random people on the street leading questions about trans issues.

The project had a preview at the November 2023 Genspect anti-trans conference.

Resources

The Signal Productions (thesignalproductions.com)

Twitter (twitter.com)

Locals (locals.com)

Joseph Henry Press (1992–2008) was a trade publishing arm for the National Academies Press. In 2003 the six people below were responsible for fact-checking, publishing, promoting, and defending J. Michael Bailey’s 2003 book The Man Who Would Be Queen, one of the most transphobic books ever written.

People involved

Barbara Kline Pope

  • Joseph Henry Press Director. Responsible for the entire vetting and publishing process.

Stephen Mautner

  • Executive Editor. Responsible for all editing and fact-checking. Stated Bailey’s book “was reviewed as a well-crafted and responsible work.”

Jeffrey Robbins

  • Senior Editor. Directly involved in editing and fact-checking. Bailey states Robbins “made my writing better than I could.” (pp. xii-xiii)

Robin Pinnel

  • Publicist. Apart from a timeline she prepared, she says all materials attributed to her were written by senior leadership.

Ann Merchant

  • Marketing Director. Associated with a collection of blurbs for the book that appeared in the press kit.

Suzanne H. Woolsey

  • Chief Communications Officer, National Academy of Sciences. Sent a form letter to anyone who wrote to express concern.

Background

Joseph Henry Press published 112 titles between 1992 and 2008. They are best known for their work promoting sociobiology.

Marketing material

Publisher descriptions (pre-publication + published versions)

Gay, Straight or Lying? Science has the answer [attributed to Robin Pinnel] March 21, 2003

New book on homosexuality, transsexualism and science [attributed to Robin Pinnel] April 2, 2003

Press release (28 April 2003)

Advocate advertisement (10 June 2003)

National Academies Press website (retrieved June 2003)

Stephen Mautner’s open letter

Press release [pdf]

Reviews excerpted for publicity (click authors for more details)

Praise

After I started systematically tracking down the reviews listed in the original Praise (PDF) document, the marketing team started adding others to the book’s webpage as they became available. Most of the praise was written by Bailey’s colleagues. Some wrote more than one review. I tracked down all the authors where possible, listed here as:

Joseph Henry Press credit [Author]

* James Cantor attribution added upon request of American Psychological Association DIV 44, August 2003

** Quotation removed August 2003

*** Simon LeVay quotation removed July 2003, added back September 2003

Selected letters

See also the following letters to those who oversee Joseph Henry Press from prominent scientists and activists:

Comments

Susan Haack’s essay “Science, Scientism, and Anti-Science in the Age of Preposterism” which was published in the Skeptical Inquirer back in 1997:

http://www.csicop.org/si/9711/preposterism.html

https://skepticalinquirer.org/1997/11/science_scientism_and_anti_science_in_the_age_of_preposterism/

This sheds some light on the academic culture that encouraged the JHP to publish Bailey’s book. Her thesis is basically that as the academic community adopts business values, it starts to judge scholarship by how well it sells rather than how well it answers questions. I think the following quote pretty much exactly describes how TMWWBQ got published:

“It used to be an important role of the academic presses to publish significant books too specialized to be economic. Increasingly, however, as subsidies from their universities have shrunk, university presses seek to publish books they believe will make money. This too is discouraging, to put it mildly, to the investment of effort in difficult problems. Better, from the point of view of making oneself heard, to write the kind of book that might interest a trade publisher, or at least the kind of book that will get reviewed in the non-academic press. And this too, inevitably, favors the simple, startling idea, even, or perhaps especially, the startlingly false or impressively obscure idea. . . .”

Publisher description

2002 pre-publication version

A frank and fascinating look at what science has to tell us about sex and gender identity written by a leading authority on this very complicated subject. Equally important, the book explores some deeply personal and often strikingly poignant stories of femininity, masculinity, and gender confusion.

2003 to present version

Gay. Straight. Or lying. It’s as simple and straightforward as black or white, right? Or is there a gray area, where the definitions of sex and gender become blurred or entirely refocused with the deft and practiced use of a surgeon’s knife? For some, the concept of gender – the very idea we have of ourselves as either male or female beings – is neither simple nor straightforward.

Written by cutting-edge researcher and sex expert J. Michael Bailey, The Man Who Would Be Queen is a frankly controversial, intensely poignant, and boldly forthright book about sex and gender. Based on his original research, Bailey’s book is grounded firmly in science. But as he demonstrates, science doesn’t always deliver predictable or even comfortable answers. Indeed, much of what he has to say will be sure to generate as many questions as it does answers.

Are gay men genuinely more feminine than other men? And do they really prefer to be hairdressers rather than lumberjacks? Are all male transsexuals women trapped in men’s bodies – or are some of them men who are just plain turned on by the idea of becoming a woman? And how much of a role do biology and genetics play in sexual orientation?

But while Bailey’s science is provocative, it is the portraits of the boys and men who struggle with these questions – and often with anger, fear, and hurt feelings – that will move you. You will meet Danny, an eight-year old boy whose favorite game is playing house and who yearns to dress up as a princess for Halloween. And Martin, an expert makeup artist who was plagued by inner turmoil as a youth but is now openly homosexual and has had many men as sex partners. And Kim, a strikingly sexy transsexual who still has a penis and works as a dancer and a call girl for men who like she-males while she awaits sex reassignment surgery.

These and other stories make it clear that there are men – and men who become women – who want only to understand themselves and the society that makes them feel like outsiders. That there are parents, friends, and families that seek answers to confusing and complicated questions. And that there are researchers who hope one day to grasp the very nature of human sexuality. As the striking cover image – a distinctly muscular and obviously male pair of legs posed in a pair of low-heeled pumps – makes clear, the concept of gender, the very idea we have of ourselves as either male or female beings, is neither simple nor straightforward for some.

Resources

Lynn Conway (lynnconway.com)

Joseph Henry Press (jhpress.org) [archive]

National Academies Press (nap.edu)

Michelle DiMeo was on the 2003 selection committee for the Lambda Literary Awards. This committee voted to honor The Man Who Would Be Queen by J. Michael Bailey as a finalist for an award in the trans category in February 2004.

Michelle DiMeo works with Pam Harcourt, who is also on the committee.

Michelle DiMeo and Pam Harcourt

Women and Children First
5233 N. Clark St. Chicago, IL 60640 
773.769.9299 
Fax: 773.769.6729 
[email protected] 
http://www.womenandchildrenfirst.com

On 24 February 2004, the selection committee including Sara Look voted to retain the nomination of this book over the objections of transexual people and other concerned parties around the world.

In March 2004, the committee reconsidered and withdrew this nomination.

I will publish any comments or responses from Sara Look regarding this matter as I receive them.

Other resources

Lambda Literary Foundation index page

LINK: Full Lambda Literary Award coverage (by Professor Lynn Conway)

Richard Hanania is an American political scientist, right-wing eugenicist, and anti-transgender extremist. 

In 2021 Hanania began hosting a podcast via Center for the Study of Partisanship and Ideology (CSPI). Guests include other anti-trans extremists, including Chris RufoAaron Sibarium, Eric Kaufmann, Michael ShellenbergerRazib KhanSteven Pinker, and Jesse Singal.

2023

  • Brian Riedl NOV 20, 2023
  • Niklas Anzinger OCT 30, 2023
  • Chris Rufo JUL 24, 2023
  • Leopold Aschenbrenner MAY 15, 2023
  • Bryan Caplan MAY 1, 2023
  • Robin Hanson MAR 13, 2023
  • Nicholas Bagley FEB 27, 2023
  • Tim Miller FEB 13, 2023
  • Jobst Landgrebe, Barry Smith JAN 30, 2023
  • Joe Henrich JAN 16, 2023
  • Garett Jones JAN 2, 2023

2022

  • Alexander Young DEC 19, 2022
  • Aaron Sibarium DEC 5, 2022
  • Jonathan Anomaly NOV 21, 2022
  • Rob Henderson, Zach Goldberg NOV 7, 2022
  • Eric Kaufmann OCT 24, 2022
  • Alex Tabarrok OCT 10, 2022
  • Bryan Caplan SEP 26, 2022
  • Tyler Cowen SEP 12, 2022
  • Amy Wax AUG 29, 2022
  • Stephen Grugett, James Grugett AUG 15, 2022
  • Andrew Kenneson, Maxwell Tabarrok, Brent Skorup AUG 1, 2022
  • Richard Lowery JUL 18, 2022
  • David Bernstein JUL 4, 2022
  • Seth Stephens-Davidowitz JUN 20, 2022
  • Eric Kaufmann JUN 6, 2022
  • Bryan Caplan MAY 23, 2022
  • Eron Wolf MAY 18, 2022
  • Jordan Lasker MAY 9, 2022
  • Philippe Lemoine APR 25, 2022
  • Gail Heriot APR 11, 2022
  • Noah Carl MAR 28, 2022
  • Steve Hsu MAR 14, 2022
  • Jimmy Soni FEB 28, 2022
  • Steve Hsu FEB 14, 2022
  • Alec Stapp JAN 31, 2022
  • Freddie deBoer JAN 17, 2022
  • Jonah Davids JAN 3, 2022

2021

  • Charles Fain Lehman, Gabriel Rossman DEC 20, 2021
  • Philippe Lemoine DEC 6, 2021
  • Leif Rasmussen NOV 22, 2021
  • Robert Plomin NOV 8, 2021
  • Michael Shellenberger OCT 25, 2021
  • Razib Khan OCT 11, 2021
  • Steven Pinker SEP 27, 2021
  • Robin Hanson SEP 13, 2021
  • Noor Siddiqui AUG 30, 2021
  • Marc Andreessen AUG 16, 2021
  • Philippe Lemoine AUG 2, 2021
  • Eric Posner JUL 19, 2021
  • Razib Khan JUL 5, 2021
  • Mark Lutter JUN 21, 2021
  • Sean McMeekin JUN 7, 2021
  • Jesse Singal MAY 24, 2021
  • Bryan Caplan MAY 10, 2021
  • Garett Jones APR 26, 2021
  • John Mueller APR 12, 2021
  • Philippe Lemoine MAR 15, 2021
  • Eric Kaufmann MAR 2, 2021 & MAR 29, 2021
  • Razib Khan FEB 4, 2021
  • Zach Goldberg JAN 22, 2021
  • George Hawley JAN 9, 2021

Chandler Ellis Burr (born 1963) is an American journalist and perfume curator. Burr is known for his hereditarian views on sexual orientation and sex differences, and he claims that his critics “hate science.”

Burr was on the roster of the Human Biodiversity Institute (HBI), a hereditarian organization created by conservative businessman Steve Sailer.

Background

Burr was born in Chicago and graduated from Christian Science school Principia College. He then worked in the Southeast Asia bureau of The Christian Science Monitor. Burr later wrote for The Atlantic and US News & World Report. He identifies as gay and atheist and has written extensively about the perfume industry.

Views on sexual orientation

Following a 1993 Atlantic cover story on “homosexuality and biology,” Burr expanded that work into the 1996 book A Separate Creation: The Search for the Biological Origins of Sexual Orientation. That book also briefly covers the search of causes of gender identity and expression.

Views on bisexuality

As with many other HBI members, Burr has defended controversial psychologist J. Michael Bailey, in particular Bailey’s claims that men are “straight, gay, or lying,” a pernicious belief among some biased gay men and sexologists that male bisexuality doesn’t exist.

Burr wrote the following after New York Times journalist Benedict Carey presented an uncritical look at Bailey’s claims the bisexual men are “lying.”

The passage in bold perfectly summarizes why people like Burr can’t see their bias. Burr believes that because both “the right” and “the left” take issue with his spurious views, that Burr must be correct. This is a classic “argument to moderation” fallacy.

July 12, 2005

To the Editor:

Some gay and bisexual advocates are condemning “Straight, Gay or Lying?” regarding a study suggesting that bisexuality may not exist among human males – something those of us familiar with the scientific literature have known since, basically, forever.

Compare this hysterical – and anti-science – reaction to the conservative Christians’ anti-science reaction to studies showing that homosexuality is an inborn orientation like left-handedness. They’re identical.

The right hates science because the data contradict (in the case of homosexuality) Leviticus; the left because the data contradict the liberal lie that we’re environment-created, not hard-wired in any way.

These particular scientific facts are making these advocates scream like members of the extreme right, though it’s they who always tells the right to let go of concepts that are contradicted by science.

Chandler Burr
New York
The writer is the author of “A Separate Creation: The Search for the Biological Origins of Sexual Orientation.”

Resources

Chandler Burr (chandlerburr.com)

ProCon (procon.org)