The mature minor doctrine and gender diverse youth

Transgender hormone blockers, hormones, and surgery are generally only available to minors whose parents give consent in consultation with the minor and medical experts.

In some cases, these mature minors may be able to give medical consent for puberty suppressing drugs as part of a harm reduction model of care. In some cases, a mature minor may even be able to make medical decisions that go against the wishes of their parent or guardian.

The legal doctrine is similar to providing minors drugs for contraception or treatment for sexually transmitted infections without parental consent. Some key points from Dubin:

Importantly, the mature minor doctrine is an ethical principle, and its applicability does not necessarily grant legality to a decision-making process. The law’s recognition is both limited and patchwork. Within the USA, 34 states have no legal exceptions in place for mature minors and only 14 states permit mature minors to consent to general medical treatment.

Ultimately, allowing transgender minors to consent to gender-affirming treatment, that is, over-riding parental consent, should be sought only when all other avenues to try to bring caretakers around have failed or if approaching them poses a clear and present risk to the minor’s well-being. The discussion of such approaches is outside the scope of this paper. The avenues discussed previously should be considered only after attempts to reconcile parent–child disagreement with psychosocial intervention have been thoroughly pursued.

Although guidance is not law, the capacity of a transgender minor should be strongly advocated for in a matter consistent with a provider’s general treatment of adolescents in any other medical decision-making settings such as STI services and contraception. The clinician should consider the decision to pursue hormone therapy or surgery in relation to current guidelines, risks to the individual patient and the child’s decision-making capacity.

Dubin (2020)

References

Ikuta E (March 2, 2016). Overcoming the Parental Veto: How transgender adolescents can access puberty-suppressing hormone treatment in the absence of consent under the mature minor doctrine. Southern California Interdisciplinary Law Journal Vol. 25:179. (PDF)

Dubin S, Lane M, Morrison S, Radix A, Belkind U, Vercler C, Inwards-Breland D (2020). Medically assisted gender affirmation: when children and parents disagree. Journal of Medical Ethics 2020;46:295-299. [full text] (PDF) https://doi.org/10.1136/medethics-2019-105567

Clark BA, Virani A (2021). This Wasn’t a Split-Second Decision”: An Empirical Ethical Analysis of Transgender Youth Capacity, Rights, and Authority to Consent to Hormone Therapy. Journal of Bioethical Inquiry 2021; 18(1): 151–164. doi: 10.1007/s11673-020-10086-9

Abel, B.S. 2014. Hormone treatment of children and adolescents with gender dysphoria: An ethical analysis. Hastings Center Report 44(s4): S23–S27. [PubMed]

Ashley, F. 2019. Gatekeeping hormone replacement therapy for transgender patients is dehumanising. Journal of Medical Ethics 45: 480–482. [PubMed]

Baltieri, D.A., F.C.P. Cortez, and A.G. de Andrade. 2009. Ethical conflicts over the management of transsexual adolescents: Report of two cases. The Journal of Sexual Medicine 6(11): 3214–3220. [PubMed]

Bird, S. 2011. Consent to medical treatment: The mature minor. Australian Family Physician 40(3): 159–160. [PubMed]

Carroll, M. 2009. Transgender youth, adolescent decision making, and Roper v. Simmons. UCLA Law Review 56(3): 725–753.

Cavanaugh, T., R. Hopwood, and C. Lambert. 2016. Informed consent in the medical care of transgender and gender-nonconforming patients. The AMA Journal of Ethics 18(11): 1147–1155. [PubMed]

Clark, B.A. 2018. Ethics and youth gender health care: Hormone therapy initiation decision-making of transgender youth, parents, and health care providers. PhD dissertation, The University of British Columbia.

Clark, B.A., S.K. Marshall, and E.M. Saewyc. 2020a. Hormone therapy decision-making processes: Transgender youth and parents. Journal of Adolescence 79: 136–147. [PubMed]

Clark, B.A., J.F. Veale, D. Greyson, and E. Saewyc. 2018. Primary care access and foregone care: A survey of transgender adolescents and young adults. Family Practice 35(3): 302–306. [PMC free article] [PubMed]

Clark, B.A., A. Virani, S.K. Marshall, and E.M. Saewyc. 2020b. Conditions for shared decision making in the care of transgender youth in Canada. Health Promotion International. ePub ahead of print. [PubMed]

Clark, B.A., A. Virani, and E.M. Saewyc. 2020c. “The edge of harm and help”: Ethical considerations in the care of transgender youth with complex family situations. Ethics & Behavior 30(3): 161–180.

Giordano, S. 2007. Gender atypical organisation in children and adolescents: Ethico-legal issues and a proposal for new guidelines. The International Journal of Children’s Rights 15(3-4): 365–390.

Greydanus, D.E., and D.R. Patel. 1991. Consent and confidentiality in adolescent health care. Pediatric Annals 20(2): 80–84. [PubMed]

Gridley, S.J., J.M. Crouch, Y. Evans, et al. 2016. Youth and caregiver perspectives on barriers to gender-affirming health care for transgender youth. Journal of Adolescent Health 59(3): 254–261. [PubMed]

Hidalgo, M.A., D. Ehrensaft, A.C. Tishelman, et al. 2013. The gender affirmative model: What we know and what we aim to learn. Human Development 56(5): 285–290.

Michaud, P.-A., R.W. Blum, L. Benaroyo, J. Zermatten, and V. Baltag. 2015. Assessing an adolescent’s capacity for autonomous decision-making in clinical care. Journal of Adolescent Health 57(4): 361–366. [PubMed]

Olson, J., C. Forbes, and M. Belzer. 2011. Management of the transgender adolescent. Archives of Pediatrics & Adolescent Medicine 165(2): 171–176. [PubMed]

Reisner, S.L., J. Bradford, R. Hopwood, et al. 2015. Comprehensive transgender healthcare: The gender affirming clinical and public health model of Fenway Health. Journal of Urban Health 92(3): 584–592. [PMC free article] [PubMed]

Rhodes, R., and I.R. Holzman. 2014. Is the best interest standard good for pediatrics? Pediatrics 134(Supplement 2): S121–S129. [PMC free article] [PubMed]

Romero, K., and R. Reingold. 2013. Advancing adolescent capacity to consent to transgender-related health care in Colombia and the USA. Reproductive Health Matters 21(41): 186–195. [PubMed]

Schulz, S.L. 2018. The informed consent model of transgender care: An alternative to the diagnosis of gender dysphoria. Journal of Humanistic Psychology 58(1): 72–92.

Shield, S. 2007. The doctor won’t see you now: Rights of transgender adolescents to sex reassignment treatment. New York University Review of Law & Social Change 31(2): 361–434. [PubMed]

Stein, E. 2012. Commentary on the treatment of gender variant and gender dysphoric children and adolescents: Common themes and ethical reflections. Journal of Homosexuality 59(3): 480–500. [PubMed]

Swann, S.K., and S.E. Herbert. 2009. Ethical issues in the mental health treatment of trans adolescents. In Social work practice with transgender and gender variant youth, 2nd ed., edited by G.P. Mallon, 38–52. New York: Routledge.

Weithorn, L.A., and S.B. Campbell. 1982. The competency of children and adolescents to make informed treatment decisions. Child Development 53(6): 1589–1598. [PubMed]

Resources

National Center for Transgender Equality (transequality.org)

  • Identification Documents and Transgender People (PDF)

HealthLinkBC (healthlinkbc.ca)