Anne Lawrence and transgender people

Anne Alexandra Lawrence (born November 17, 1950) is an American sexologist and former anesthesiologist who is the most prominent transgender “autogynephilia” activist in history. Lawrence is author of the 2013 book Men Trapped in Men’s Bodies: Narratives of Autogynephilic Transsexualism.

Many people (including me) have come forward with observations and first-hand reports where Lawrence performed inappropriately sexual “medical” exams. Following a 1997 resignation for examining an unconscious patient for signs of ritualized genital modification, the bulk of Lawrence’s personal and professional life has been dedicated to promoting the “autogynephilia” diagnosis. Lawrence has since worked closely with Ray Blanchard, the Toronto sexologist who invented this diagnosis in 1989.

Background

Lawrence earned a Bachelor’s degree in Chemistry from University of Chicago in 1971, then a medical degree from University of Minnesota in 1974, with a specialty in anesthesia. Lawrence began taking hormones in medical school but stopped at some point. Lawrence took an anesthesiologist position at Swedish Medical Center in Seattle, Washington.

Lawrence got married in 1987 and had two children. Lawrence began making a gender transition again 1992, ending the marriage in 1995 and transitioning at work soon after.

In July 1996, Lawrence created Transsexual Women’s Resources, one of the most important early online resources for trans medical information, later housed at annelawerence.com. Much of it was first-hand reports, such as Lawrence’s 1996 essay about vaginoplasty with Toby Meltzer titled “Taking Portlandia’s Hand.” It also had the largest collection of vaginoplasty information and results from around the world, captioned with Lawrence’s personal opinions about the results. Many of the images of results were taken by Lawrence, often at community gatherings or at Lawrence’s home. Lawrence has since removed most of the material and excluded it from archival sites.

“Autogynephilia” activism

Lawrence discovered the disease “autogynephilia” in 1994 after reading Blanchard’s journal articles published between 1989 and 1993. Lawrence then began proselytizing for “autogynephilic transsexual” as an identity at gender conventions, finding few community supporters.

Via Ekins and King (2001):

It soon emerged from her papers, that Lawrence, after periods of personal confusion, ‘found herself’ with reference to Blanchard’s concept, in much the same way that so many transgendered people speak of ‘finding themselves’ when first becoming acquainted and adopting the medical terms ‘transvestite’ or ‘transsexual’.

Via Ekins and King (2012):

Lawrence says that on reading Blanchard’s journal articles that she experienced the ‘kind of epiphany that trans people often feel when first coming across words and formulations that fit and work for them’ (Lawrence 1999a). Not only do they feel empowered to make sense of their predicament, but the formulations are proof to them that they are not alone.

In 1996, Lawrence began promoting the disease online, which brought Lawrence to the attention of sexologists promoting it. They began to shower Lawrence with attention and validation.

1997 hospital resignation

In 1997, Lawrence was accused by coworkers of examining an unconscious Ethiopian patient for signs of ritualized genital modification during a medical procedure. That triggered a state investigation, and Lawrence resigned prior to the full investigation.

The incident was not widely publicized until trans activist Roberta Angela Dee published a 2002 exposé that included excerpts from the case file from the State of Washington.

I later obtained the complete adverse action report from the state.

Reinvention as sexologist

Lawrence began focusing more on online resources following the failure of her marriage and anesthesiology career, but as she became more and more focused on “autogynephilia” activism, the trans community began to turn on her as well.

Lawrence and I both ran prominent websites on gender transition, and we began discussing collaboration on a book, to the point that we met in person at her home in 1999. Her website at the time contained photographic examples of vaginoplasty results, and I agreed to let her photograph my results provided they were not connected to my name. At the end of the photography session, Lawrence came on to me while I was still getting dressed, which I considered inappropriate. In a 2003 exposé, Dallas Denny published a similar account of Lawrence doing the same thing to journalist Donna Cartwright.

Eventually, Lawrence’s primary source of attention and validation was from “experts” who promoted disease models of gender identity and expression. Soon Lawrence was invited to speak at their conventions and publish in journals supportive of disease models.

Lawrence returned to school to study sexology at the Institute for Advanced Study of Human Sexuality, an unaccredited school in San Francisco. That school gave Lawrence a PhD in 2001. Lawrence later studied clinical psychology at Argosy University, Seattle, which gave Lawrence a Master’s Degree in 2006. Both schools have since ceased operations.

In 2008, prominent “autogynephilia” activist Paul Vasey brought Lawrence on as an adjunct professor in his psychology department at at University of Lethbridge.

Lawrence on Bailey (2003)

Lawrence has also worked closely with another Blanchard supporter, psychologist J. Michael Bailey of Northwestern University. Bailey had self-published a 2000 article online called “Transsexualism: Women trapped in men’s bodies or men who would be women?” That work was incorporated into Bailey’s 2003 book The Man Who Would Be Queen. Lawrence is quoted on the cover, calling it “a wonderful book on an important subject,” despite the fact that nearly everyone else who read it found it to be one of the most defamatory and inaccurate books on gender variance since 1979.

When readers started posting negative Amazon reviews, Bailey enlisted his friends and colleagues to write shill reviews. Lawrence published the anonymous review below:

Outstanding scholarship, April 18, 2003
Reviewer: A reader from USA

Michael Bailey’s new book offers an entertaining, informative, and provocative discussion of gender variance in biologic males. The author is Professor and Chair of the Department of Psychology at Northwestern University, and is one of the world’s foremost authorities on gender and sexual orientation. Fortunately for readers, he is a superb writer as well as a gifted scholar.

The author’s detailed discussion of femininity and masculinity in gay men is outstanding, and his treatment of male-to-female transsexuality is remarkable for its insight and compassion. Bailey is not afraid to be politically incorrect, and some of his conclusions are bound to upset the handful of transsexuals who still cling to the “I was a woman trapped in a man’s body” fantasy. But many more transsexuals will be grateful for the author’s willingness to go beyond the stereotypes and clichés and reveal the complicated truths about their lives.

If you want comfortable homilies, read Mildred Brown or Randi Ettner. If you want the truth, read Bailey.

Below may be the most succinct expression of Dr. Lawrence’s position I’ve seen. It is the rigid medical model of “sex” combined with Dr. Lawrence’s fluid foray into identity politics by claiming to be transsexual that is the issue here (emphasis mine).

I should explain that I will be using the term “transsexual” in its most literal sense, to mean one who desires to approximate as closely as possible the anatomic characteristics of the opposite sex. Note that the word “gender” does not appear in my definition. This reflects my belief that transsexuality is fundamentally about changing one’s anatomy, or sex; and that sometimes it may have little to do with gender identity, or with gender role.

My message today is that some biologic males who pursue sex reassignment do so, not primarily because they have a gender problem, but because they have a sex problem, and indeed a sexual problem. I will explain why I have come to believe that male-to-female transsexualism is sometimes the expression of a paraphilia — an unusual or variant pattern of sexual arousal.

http://www.annelawrence. com/1999hbigda1.html

Commentaries on Lawrence

 Anne Lawrence: The Anne Who Would Be Queen

 Wannabes?

 Anne Lawrence and Fundamentalism

 Pink triangulation

References

Ekins R, King D (2001). Transgendering, Migrating and Love of Oneself as a Woman: A Contribution to a Sociology of Autogynephilia. International Journal of Transgenderism 5,3, http://www.symposion.com/ijt/ijtvo05no03_01.htm

Zagria (17 March 2009). Anne Lawrence (1950 – ) anesthesiologist, gender therapist, activist. A Gender Variance Who’s Who. https://zagria.blogspot.com/2009/03/anne-lawrence-1950-anesthesiologist.html

State of Washington (1997). Anne Lawrence investigation (PDF)

State of Washington (1997). Anne Lawrence medical license record (PDF)

[Denny, Dallas] (2004). Concerns about Dr. Anne Lawrence. Transgender Tapestry; Spring 2004, Issue 105, p. 13.

Resources

Anne Lawrence: publications

Anne Lawrence websites

  • annelawrence.com
  • members.aol.com/tssource
  • mindspring.com/~alawrence