Site icon Transgender Map

Transgender athletes

Sports are an important part of life for many people, including many transgender people.

Children

For all children, including gender diverse and transgender children, participating in sports can help psychosocial development by teaching important life skills like discipline, respect, persistence, dedication, and patience. Sports can improve a child’s health, mood, and self-esteem. All children deserve to experience those things.

Youth and adolescents

As more and more youth and adolescents make a gender transition, some people have expressed concern about transgender athletes in competitive sports. This is especially true in sex-segregated sports, where some people question if it is fair for transgender athletes to compete with non-transgender athletes. This concern most often arises around transgender women and girls participating in a sport with non-transgender women and girls.

That concern is sometimes heightened by the level of competition and what can be won. For instance, earning a ribbon or trophy is valuable, but winning a local, state, regional, national, or international competition can lead to other opportunities and sometimes has financial value. Notable adolescent athletes who are transgender include:

Balancing fairness with inclusion is very complicated, and every athletic organization all the way up to the Olympics wants to find the best path forward.

In 2021, a number of US state legislatures considered laws around trans minors participating in sex-segregated sports. The Human Rights Campaign put together this profile of Rebekah, a student-athlete affected by these laws.

Adults

Transgender adults participate in sports at all levels of ability, from casual participant to professional athlete.

Did not compete after gender transition

A number of transgender people were noted athletes before transition, but they did not compete in their sports after making a gender transition. They include:

Competed after gender transition

Eligibility and fairness concerns

As with transgender youth and adolescents, most concern involves adult transgender women participating in competitive sex-segregated sports. Discussions about this go all the way back to the 1936 Olympics, and the International Olympic Committee has issued many revised regulations on sex testing and physiological thresholds for sex categories.

In the 20th century, some organizations required physical examinations of athletes’ naked bodies. Several track and field athletes had their eligibility challenged based on these exams:

Some organizations later required chromosome testing. Several athletes had their eligibility challenged based on these exams:

Later, some organizations began hormone testing. Some created policies for women with “hyperandrogenism,” an unusually high level of naturally-produced androgen like testosterone. Several athletes had their eligibility challenged based on these exams:

In women’s boxing Algeria’s Imane Khelif and Taiwan’s Lin Yu-ting competed in the 2024 Olympics. Neither athlete identifies as trans or intersex. Both were disqualified from the 2023 International Boxing Association (IBA) championship due to an unspecified gender eligibility test, which has different eligibility criteria than the IOC. The IBA has since been decertified as the governing international body of boxing.

Many of the cases above led to long legal fights. In some cases, the athletes were found to have differences of sex development. In some cases, they later made a gender transition and identified as men. Some won their cases, and others lost.

Organized political opposition

The first major organized backlash against trans athletes emerged in 1976, when Renee Richards began playing tennis professionally. Richards successfully sued the United States Tennis Association for imposing genetic requirements on athletes. Richards played professionally from 1977 to 1981, reaching a high ranking of 20th and having most success in doubles. An anti-transgender movement began to coalesce around that time, with sex-segregated sports being a major flashpoint.

Other notable backlashes have occurred following success by some trans athletes, including:

In the 21st century, several organizations explicitly dedicated to maintaining sex segregation in sport emerged.

The future of sex segregation

Most of these discussions center on physical competitive advantages, but in 2023 The International Chess Federation (FIDE) unveiled a controversial policy claiming that sex-segregated chess is needed because cisgender women are mentally disadvantaged. For many, this policy exposed larger questions about any kind of segregation, including sex segregation:

Current debates about sex-segregated competitive sport eclipse these larger ethical issues. Some people argue that sex segregation in general, and sex-segregated competitive sports in particular, reinforce sexism and are thus antithetical to human progress. Most of the world is not ready to consider the ethical problems of either sex-segregated sport or competitive sport.

References

Sports Councils’ Equality Group (September 2021). The UK’s Sports Councils Guidance for Transgender Inclusion in Domestic Sport. https://movingtoinclusion.co.uk/wp-content/uploads/2023/07/Guidance-For-Transgender-Inclusion-In-Domestic-Sport-2021.pdf

Ann Travers, Eric Anderson (2017). Transgender Athletes in Competitive Sport. Taylor & Francis, ISBN 9781315304250

Amy M. West (2023). The Transgender Athlete: A Guide for Sports Medicine Providers. Academic Press, ISBN 9780323916202

Joanna Harper (2019). Sporting Gender: The History, Science, and Stories of Transgender and Intersex Athletes. Rowman & Littlefield Publishers, ISBN 9781538112977

Resources

Each amateur and professional competitive sport has its own governing body, so there’s no general rule about how this is handled in sex-segregated sport. The resources below have additional information on this complex topic.

TransAthlete (transathlete.com)

Let Us Play (letusplay.team)

GLSEN (glsen.org)

Athlete Ally (athleteally.org)

National Collegiate Athletic Association (ncaa.com)

Canadian Centre for Ethics in Sport (cces.ca)

World Athletics (worldathletics.org)

 International Olympic Committee (olympic.org)

Archival resources

Veronica Ivy (drveronicaivy.com) [archive]


Exit mobile version